Home / Texas Home Insurance Locations / Carthage
Home Insurance in Carthage, TX
From build years to owner-occupancy, the makeup of Carthage’s housing explains much of what insurers ask. This guide starts with the homes themselves.
What Carthage housing looks like
In Carthage, 64% of occupied homes are lived in by their owners and 69% of units are detached houses.
Why build year matters in Carthage
The median home in Carthage was built in 1977. The split is roughly 58% pre-1980 construction versus 25% built from 2000 on. With a stock this mature, insurers often want the roof age and the year the electrical panel and plumbing were last updated before they bind coverage.
$3,927/yr
About $327/mo · ~$300k-$400k dwelling class
$2,305/yr
About $192/mo after modeled shopping discount
About 41.3% below local market estimate
Setting the dwelling limit in Carthage
The typical owner-occupied home in Carthage is valued at about $164,200. It tracks the county median of $158,100 fairly closely. Sale prices and rebuild costs can diverge in either direction, which is why carriers run their own replacement-cost estimate for the dwelling limit.
What each coverage does for Carthage owners
Covers the house. Lenders require it, and it is the base that percentage deductibles are calculated from.
Anything not attached to the house, such as fences, carports and barns. Larger lots and outbuildings are common here, so check the limit.
Your belongings. A room-by-room photo inventory makes claims faster.
Loss of use. After a large storm, contractor backlogs can stretch repairs, so this limit matters.
Covers lawsuits for injuries or property damage you are responsible for; many owners choose at least $300,000.
Small medical bills for guests injured at your home, regardless of fault.
Hazards Carthage homes are exposed to
FEMA’s county-level National Risk Index puts Panola County in the relatively low band overall. Hazard by hazard, the strongest scores are for strong wind (relatively high), ice storms (relatively high) and hail (relatively moderate). Panola County had 20 hail reports in NOAA’s storm records for 2016 through 2025. 19 of those involved stones an inch or larger, the size that commonly damages shingles. The top report was 3.5-inch hail on June 13, 2023.
Since Panola County is not a TWIA county, look at how your homeowners policy handles wind and hail, including whether that deductible is a flat amount or a percentage of the dwelling limit. The FEMA Flood Map Service Center shows the flood zone for any address.
Records to check before you quote
Before you request quotes, pull your record from the Panola appraisal district at www.panolacad.org; the Texas Comptroller’s Panola County directory lists its contact details. You can also visit the office at 1736 Ball Park Dr. Carthage, TX 75633-3368.
Carthage sits within Panola County. No metro or micro area includes Panola County, so it is rural by the federal definition. Measured point to point, Carthage sits roughly 35 miles southeast of Longview.
Common questions from Carthage homeowners
Are most homes in Carthage old or new?
The median home was built in 1977, and about 58% predate 1980, per Census estimates. Older systems mean more underwriting questions, so have dates for the roof, panel and plumbing ready.
Should I insure my Carthage home for its market value?
Not necessarily. The Census median home value in Carthage is $164,200, but Coverage A should match the cost to rebuild, which excludes land and can be higher or lower than market value. Ask for a replacement-cost estimate based on square footage and finishes.
What does the Carthage savings estimate on this page mean?
The estimate cards above model about 41.3% below the local market figure for Carthage. Treat it as illustrative; your quote depends on the home, roof, claims history and deductible.
How often should I shop coverage in Carthage?
Check before each renewal. Carriers adjust rates and underwriting appetite over time, so last year’s best price may not hold.
Get a Carthage home insurance quote
Texas Insurance Resources shops multiple carriers for you. Call 800-875-4711 or start online.
Sources for this Carthage page
Figures were retrieved in October 2026 and are estimates with margins of error. Price estimates near the top are Texas Insurance Resources models for comparison, not quotes or published averages.
- FEMA National Risk Index, Panola County
- Comptroller economic regions
- American Community Survey 2020–2024, Carthage city: population, year built, median year built, home value, structure type, tenure
- Census metro delineation
- Census Gazetteer files
- Benchmarks: Panola County value, Panola County build year
- Comptroller county directory, Panola County
- NOAA Storm Events Database, Panola County
- Texas Windstorm Insurance Association